Denver Officer Terminated for Failure to Follow Alarm Policy; 2 Dead in Fire Soon After
Elderly Couple Die in House Fire 20 Minutes After Denver Officer Failed to Investigate Their Silent Burglar Alarm
On May 7, around 4 a.m. on a rainy and windy night, now former Denver Police Officer Evan Potter was dispatched to a residential home in Denver’s Washington Virginia Vale neighborhood because of a silent burglar alarm. Internal affairs reports show that Potter spent less than a minute on the home’s street and “a matter of seconds” at the house itself, never leaving his car. Within 20 minutes, the Denver Fire Department was pulling an elderly couple out of that home as it was engulfed in flames. The couple died soon after from smoke asphyxiation.
Potter was terminated for cause Sept. 22 due to failing to follow policy regarding investigating silent alarms at residences. The internal investigations files clarify that “there is no way to determine if different actions by Officer Potter would have prevented the deaths,” but “had he exited his vehicle to conduct even a minimal investigation into the cause of the alarm, Officer Potter may have seen or heard signs of the fire and may have been able to notify the fire department sooner, giving the occupants a better chance of survival.”
The internal affairs document summarizes the Denver Fire Department’s fire investigation report stating that a neighbor heard three loud “pops” and saw flashes from the house and a glow coming from the back of the home. The internal affairs report found that the neighbor observed this minutes after Potter left and “suggests that the fire was in progress when Officer Potter responded to the residence.” The fire investigation classified the fire as accidental and as beginning in the family room, but a primary source of the fire could not be conclusively determined.
“I believed I could see all I was going to be able to see looking over that house, so I decided to get back in my car, close the window and door, without approaching,” Potter said in a verbal statement transcribed in the internal affairs report. He described the house as looking “vacant” with dark windows and no smoke in sight. He also stated he did not hear a smoke alarm, though he noted it was rainy and windy.
“Officer Potter did not knock on the door of the residence, attempt to look inside, or leave his vehicle to look around outside to investigate what triggered the alarm,” the internal affairs report continues. “He stated that he rolled his window down and opened the door but did not get out.”
According to the internal affairs report, Potter also stated that, in his experience, bad weather caused more alarms to be triggered.
“His assumptions generalizing this information to the incident at hand demonstrates the risk of drawing conclusions without adequate investigation,” the report states.
It concludes that “[Potter] failed to adequately investigate a silent alarm at a residence, where DFD was subsequently dispatched to extinguish a fire that resulted in two fatalities.”
Correction: The subhead previously had a typo. It has been corrected to say "20 minutes," rather than just "minutes."